Biscuits
Free Agent
Posts: 173
Likes: 219
I am Offline
Last On: Apr 13, 2020 15:14:33 GMT 1
|
Post by Biscuits on Aug 20, 2015 19:26:45 GMT 1
As Lager said these values are wrong,firstly there should be all information about players,all,not only championship but every official tournament we did like League cup,1v1 tournament,world cup and country cup,secondly all the stats about defend are joke and absolutely not correct. And is not only assist and goals,skillers and clevers players should be on top as well,and most completes players should be first.
|
|
lipton
Administrator
Posts: 66
Likes: 219
I am Offline
Last On: Nov 14, 2022 17:29:04 GMT 1
|
Post by lipton on Aug 20, 2015 20:03:16 GMT 1
Hey good job with player values, but I've got some ideas:
I think defenders scoring ability is overvalued. Defenders primary duty is to keep their own goal clean. Goals scored and assists are just bonus. Now these stats are valued higher than what forwards have. And forwards main duty is to score goals. Though I know that you defend as a team and attack as a team. One could say that it's harder for a defender to score a goal than for a forward (which is true), but so it is for a midfielder as well. So why are midfielders goals valued lower than forwards goals? If you have different values for different position, I think forwards should have the highest value for goals, midfielders second and defenders third. For assists this isn't as obvious, but I'd probably put midfielders first, forwards second and defenders third. Or keep them all as they are, your choice. Or did I even understand the valuing correctly?
This obviously would lead to a big decrease in defender values. Defenders should have their own 'goals against' indeed, but I understand why it's done this way now.
Actually I think you could remove the position midfielders and mark all of them as forwards. I think in a successful 3v3 Spaceball team there are two forwards and one defender, but I know everyone doesn't agree with me on this.
I think you could divide all player values by 1000, so we could get rid of useless zeros. It's not real money.
I've been thinking also another way to rank players. It's just an idea so keep calm and so on. I got the idea from movie The Social Network, where they rank hotness of college girls in a Facemash app. Two random girls photos are side by side and the guy chooses if left or right girl is hotter. And then the app calculates which girl has "won" most of the "battles" and creates a leaderboard. We could replace the college girls with random season 5 spaceball players and ask a question "Who is better?". This clip maybe explains the idea a little better or maybe not: .
Anyone could vote there as many times as they want. We would get the ultimate spaceball king or queen voted by the community. It's just an idea. I know we already have All Stars voting and captains choices. This would be only extra, just like player values. I can't program this myself.
|
|
alpha
Free Agent
The Future
Posts: 133
Likes: 189
I am Offline
Last On: Nov 22, 2016 18:02:57 GMT 1
|
Post by alpha on Aug 20, 2015 20:38:03 GMT 1
#InLiptonWeTrust I like that idea!
|
|
Gele
Free Agent
Posts: 817
Likes: 809
I am Offline
Last On: Oct 12, 2016 18:51:28 GMT 1
|
Post by Gele on Aug 20, 2015 22:03:10 GMT 1
- Drogba: The player values are not calculated for all seasons and tournaments yet, (they will be eventually of course), but I want to have the right calculation first. Otherwise I'm spending hours and hours calculating values, which I have to recalculate every time I make a change to it. - Biscuits, Lager and others: The defender value is calculated incorrect, as I already said and you all have let me know in different ways Because currently we do not have enough stats for it, I counted other stats higher to still give a reasonable value for defenders (mostly, goals scored and team goals against). I'm currently writing down a list of the exact stats I need, which we'll try to incorporate for next season in an easy and not too much-time consuming way. So please stop discussing this and focus on other aspects, I know about it and am working on getting the defender value right asap - lipton, I do think midfielder is okay to have, we could add a new position/change it to 'allround', or something like that, if it's not really clear what the player's main position is. Your other points concerning player value I've written down on my list. Thanks for that.
|
|