knarrrr
Free Agent
Posts: 164
Likes: 182
I am Offline
Last On: Mar 13, 2016 1:20:24 GMT 1
|
Post by knarrrr on Sept 23, 2014 23:06:00 GMT 1
awards: MVP, best 4th player, ROY (after next ssn), best offensive/defense player.
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Sept 23, 2014 23:12:15 GMT 1
I like the best def player even if many players are all arounders now... For example I was the attacking player (something like Att. Midf) with less def work but now I do much more work for the team, do def, 1v1 mark defending etc even if Im still attacking player. There should be some criterion, who is def player and who not... What do you think?
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Sept 23, 2014 23:13:45 GMT 1
and the best offensive player - I think this will be won by the best scorer (maybe assister) so this award is useless for me, to be honest... MVP maybe the same, just look how many def players were in the allstars The best 4th player is nice idea Do you want to define the 4th players by for example 200 or less minutes played ... or random?
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Sept 23, 2014 23:14:12 GMT 1
and the best offensive player - I think this will be won by the best scorer (maybe assister) so this award is useless for me, to be honest... MVP maybe the same, just look how many def players were in the allstars
|
|
knarrrr
Free Agent
Posts: 164
Likes: 182
I am Offline
Last On: Mar 13, 2016 1:20:24 GMT 1
|
Post by knarrrr on Sept 23, 2014 23:38:40 GMT 1
just saw there's an top scorer/assists award... so yes best offensive player is useless best defensive award should go to a gk (like insigne) or midfielder (like hesse) imo anybody who had less game time than 3 other players of his team should be allowed to get the 4th player award MVP is something special mutch more than top assists/ top scorer imo, lorz haven't get any of those and still had by far the most allstar votes, it isn't all about scoring my personal favorite would be insigne
|
|
Mitre
Free Agent
Posts: 26
Likes: 32
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 16, 2015 13:16:30 GMT 1
|
Post by Mitre on Sept 23, 2014 23:58:02 GMT 1
That could be done as simple as this, imho, and based in my experience in haxball leagues I've admin'ed:
- Decide awards, and requeriments for each award. - Let captains nominate ppl of their team (like, mitre for best gk, mitre2 for best mid, mitre3 for best fwd, mitre4 for 4th man) & after making a list, let them vote privately or publicly. (Something like 3 points, 2 points, 1 point...)
It's not perfect (one captain could vote a bad player to improve his team chances of getting awards) but you all here are honest and it's quite simple.
|
|
kingdulli
Free Agent
Posts: 347
Likes: 229
I am Offline
Last On: Dec 18, 2016 18:58:25 GMT 1
|
Post by kingdulli on Sept 25, 2014 1:01:13 GMT 1
create spacebounce league with draftsystem alrdy
|
|
Pepsi
Free Agent
Posts: 124
Likes: 81
I am Offline
Last On: Nov 5, 2016 14:03:15 GMT 1
|
Post by Pepsi on Sept 25, 2014 12:06:28 GMT 1
So much better!) Here are my thoughts about the tournament: - You should have more awards like haxsb; - What's the point of having a 14 minute match instead of 10 minute? - Why do teams have similar home and away kits? There is a need for a rule. For example, home and away kits should be different from each other. - Is a playoff format is a bad idea for this league? - I think it will be more comfortable if there is a haxballtube channel with all league matches and another channel with all WC matches. More awards - this is not suggestion, just tell us, what awards you want and for what 14 Minutes - ok this is question. It was played like this in the 1st spaceball french forum by Yio and after the Phillys season with 5min halves we decided to extend it to 7min, we can see more goals and 10min matches looked short. KITS - YES, THERE SHOULD BE RULE LIKE THIS there is no reason having for example red/white kits for home and white/red kits for away. Playoff - what do you think? Give us suggestion, how you want to play playoff, how much teams, whats the scheme etc... After that we can reply on it Haxballtube - idk, you can find all links on this forum and I think its clear because you can find it in google docs near by all match + in team docs + in fixtures/results so everyone can find the link for particular match - As I've already said you should have haxsb awards. knarrrr has already mentioned them. And in my opinion there is no problem with the fact that the best scorer would take it. Cause there are also best assister or a bunch of guys who scored less than the top scorer but also have less opportunities (matches or a weaker team). So there will be a wide choice anyway. 4-th player is a great idea too. And all of the awards should be decided by people's voting. - Of course there is a point for increased scoring. But is it so much better when score is like 7-6 or 13-0 than 3-2 or 1-0? - My suggestion is to have the dark and light color kits. For example, dark kits for playing "at home" or something like that. Also you could just simply forbid having almost the same home and away kits. - It depends on the amount of the teams. You could have a conference format, a divison format (the worst option as for me). But the main question is @does the league format provide you with the most ineteresting scenario when Dream team were the champions in the middle of the tournament" or you could have a final series between top 2 teams. - Probably you're right but there are always these little things like dead link or forum is down or admins haven't done it yet, so channel might be useful. Buuuuuuuuuut maybe it is just me & my thoughts and I'm just wasting my time on it)
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Sept 25, 2014 13:38:48 GMT 1
Pepsi, about the colors, its a good idea as i said before and captains should do it like this before the ssn 3 starts... about the minutes, yes, its better and also this allow giving some more chances and playing minutes to the 4th-7th player in the squad. And we will decide the league format after knowing the exact number of teams But you can post here the suggestions so they can be considered and maybe used in the league format... or generally in the league
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Likes:
I am Offline
Last On: Apr 18, 2024 18:20:56 GMT 1
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2014 14:10:18 GMT 1
Goal of the season Og of the season Save of the season
|
|