Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Aug 31, 2014 17:45:24 GMT 1
Maybe the captains could nominate the best attacking and the best defensive player from their team so there would be 10 attacking and 10 defensive players nominated overall, and when we have those 10 players in 1 category, the captains can give 5, 3 or 1 point to any player besides the ones from his team (so, every captain has 9 players to choose from) and at the end, the player with most votes wins the award. It's a bit complicated, but I think it could work.. But honestly, I think we should have only the best defensive player category. I like this idea about votes too. But also defensive player can win the MVP award so why not havint the best attacking player award too?
|
|
bonfire
Free Agent
Motherfucker
Bon to the fire.
Posts: 292
Likes: 331
I am Offline
Last On: Nov 30, 2016 22:46:53 GMT 1
|
Post by bonfire on Aug 31, 2014 17:53:37 GMT 1
Maybe the captains could nominate the best attacking and the best defensive player from their team so there would be 10 attacking and 10 defensive players nominated overall, and when we have those 10 players in 1 category, the captains can give 5, 3 or 1 point to any player besides the ones from his team (so, every captain has 9 players to choose from) and at the end, the player with most votes wins the award. It's a bit complicated, but I think it could work.. But honestly, I think we should have only the best defensive player category. I like this idea about votes too. But also defensive player can win the MVP award so why not havint the best attacking player award too? Because I'm kind of thinking that the top scoring player will be voted the best attacking player too.. but that doesn't have to be true, though
|
|
SanRoo
Free Agent
Posts: 307
Likes: 311
I am Offline
Last On: Dec 27, 2017 18:47:11 GMT 1
|
Post by SanRoo on Aug 31, 2014 18:06:20 GMT 1
Maybe the captains could nominate the best attacking and the best defensive player from their team so there would be 10 attacking and 10 defensive players nominated overall, and when we have those 10 players in 1 category, the captains can give 5, 3 or 1 point to any player besides the ones from his team (so, every captain has 9 players to choose from) and at the end, the player with most votes wins the award. It's a bit complicated, but I think it could work.. But honestly, I think we should have only the best defensive player category. I like this idea about votes too. But also defensive player can win the MVP award so why not havint the best attacking player award too? I like this Idea too, but i think an offensive player have to make scores, otherwise he isn't an offensive player?
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Aug 31, 2014 18:14:58 GMT 1
I like this idea about votes too. But also defensive player can win the MVP award so why not havint the best attacking player award too? Because I'm kind of thinking that the top scoring player will be voted the best attacking player too.. but that doesn't have to be true, though Aha i know your thought now... Ok we can discuss it
|
|
lorZ
Administrator
Posts: 335
Likes: 340
I am Offline
Last On: Mar 19, 2017 0:01:37 GMT 1
|
Post by lorZ on Aug 31, 2014 18:19:05 GMT 1
Hi 1. We should think about adding "prizes"/awards + symbols/images/icon for each award on forum... Im talking about 3v3 Spaceball League champion, TOP scorer, TOP assister 2. (ALSO the best attacking/defensive player award or Most valuable player if we will do some votes again by captains or all forumers.) 3. Hm, and as we are SpaceSports for all space sports, not only spaceball... We should talk about all tournaments winner awards. I mean the 6spaceman tournament award for Insigne, 1v1 and 2v2 SpaceSpeedGol tournament's awards for all winners on the tournaments organised by this forum. Also we will have SpaceBounce tournament soon I hope. 4. Awards for all 12 All-Stars season one (or two ) ? I think it would be nice because many great players cant win the team award but all forum voted for them. You should let us know your opinion on all 1-4. points and you can add some new suggestion too. Awards should be added to Profiles of winners and they should show in all posts they will make. 1. Yes, I agree; 2. Votes by captains, please. They are the right people to choose who are the best, not noobs who don't even have teams, for example; 3. I can't agree with those awards for other spacesports, because the other tournaments are for fun, not competitive; 4. Yes, those 12 players should have an award for playing that All-Star game.
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Sept 1, 2014 0:26:35 GMT 1
I like SanRoos idea about creating Hall of Fame where we can put all winners of tournaments and leagues and winners of individual awards in leagues. I think we could have this Hall Of Fame on the top of the page, near "Members" and "LeagueStatistics"
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Sept 1, 2014 0:32:06 GMT 1
I'm generally open to everything mentioned, but I think that if the awards show next to every post, the awards should be something "special". So don't give out too many if there is some active player who is talented and who win every tournament on all space maps... Im open to give him 10 awards near his name.
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Sept 1, 2014 0:43:15 GMT 1
1. Yes, I agree; 2. Votes by captains, please. They are the right people to choose who are the best, not noobs who don't even have teams, for example; 3. I can't agree with those awards for other spacesports, because the other tournaments are for fun, not competitive; 4. Yes, those 12 players should have an award for playing that All-Star game. I agree with your 1. and 4.your 2. - I can see problem with voting only by All star players like bonfire suggested. and votes for 3 players (1. 5pts, 2. 3pts, 3. 1pt) among them or something like this. Because if All star game has 3 players from 1 team, there is rly chance that they can agree and rig the voting a little bit. We should give this right to all players or forumers OR only to captains (and the chances for all are equal) your 3. - I disagree, i think the most of players want to win these tournaments when these players join them. Ok, its more for fun than spaceball league but for example 2v2 tournament on Phillys forum which we won together was also only 1day tournament but it wasnt rly only for fun and everyone wanted to win it. Even if many of us enjoyed it too. How you want to measure "this was only for fun and that other wasnt"?
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Jan 26, 2015 18:25:46 GMT 1
BUMP!!! Ok and now we are back to this discussion. We discussed this on LEAGUE AND FORUM discussion - spacesports.freeforums.net/thread/317/league-forum-suggestions?page=3 - with some forumers and I would like to add some prizes or change something. as knarrr said: "awards: MVP, best 4th player, ROY (after next ssn), best offensive/defense player." i said: " I like the best def player... And the best offensive player - I think this will be won by the best scorer (maybe assister) so this award is useless for me, to be honest... MVP maybe the same, just look how many def players were in the allstars (this was bullshit by me, I dont think this anymore)T he best 4th player is nice idea ..." So... Now i think, MVP (Most Valuable Player) can be nice award. I said that the best scorer OR the best assister will be the Best Offensive player too - SO I want to leave just Best Offensive player OR stay with scorer and assister (but not all three, which is useless)THe best 4th player - its nice idea, and we can count the minutes played in all teams to consider, who are the 14 (from all teams) 4th players. We can just check haxball stats, not the big problem. like knarrr said: "anybody who had less game time than 3 other players of his team should be allowed to get the 4th player award". Pepsi liked that too
And there are factors like stronger and weaker teams or minutes/matches played so maybe the best offensive can be won by somebody else, not best assister/scorer. There were suggestions also for: Goal of the season; Own goal of the season; Save of the season - i dont know discuss about these ones too.
THE FACT and MY OPINION: now we have just the best scorer and best assister. I would prefer to have also Most Valuable player (like the best player of the ssn), best defensive player and best 4th player. + maybe something more.
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Jan 26, 2015 18:42:15 GMT 1
And I think that captains of the teams should vote for this awards. And they cant vote for the players from their teams (or can?)
|
|