Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Aug 2, 2014 13:20:40 GMT 1
My points of view are... 1. As I said before, I really doubt their league is comparable to our league! Its like Polish spacebounce server wants to play Champions League game with the best team in Haxsb.com ... Or like Austrian tipico Bundesliga's champion Red Bull Salzburg wants to play supercup/championship with the Uefa Champions League champion Real Madrid for the honour "The best football team in Europe" --- This objection is for both "the championship" and the allstar game too 2. I like allstar game idea in our forum with 2 teams - 2 captains voted by all forumers and after these captains can choose their squad like in the draft. 3. If I have to choose between allstar game vs NSL or championships with 4best teams (from each league) . I like the allstar game idea more! This means more teams can participate in it at least with 1 player. I dont like the championship - I said why in "1.". 4. But I appreciate the idea on cooperation with NSL and other national leagues/forums which can help to both sides. So I vote for allstar game. And we can find more national forums, websites and try to cooperate with them too. 5. Captain of Allstar team - NOT admin (why?), I suggest that all 10 captains (not players) from this league should vote for the best captain - the captain with skills on the field, behaviour, communication skills and good manners. And only captains can say this about other captains (the players know mainly their own captain only). The captains cant vote for ourselves. 6. Selected All-star team for all-star game. I like bonfire's idea but dont do votes for positions. Many players can play as attacker and defender too, some of them knows how to play GK and attacker too. We need maybe just 1 GK. So without "polls" on positions, please. I think every player in this league should vote the players for the All-star team (but not the players from his own team). Since captains vote for the captain of All-star team. We can discuss how many votes has every player and if this voting is hidden or not (I prefer hidden one). 1. Okay, your opinion is legit. So, why not play this cup and this all-star game to see if the difference is that big? Maybe they could surprise you. 2. If the community and other admins want, we could do a all-star game in our forum too. 3. and 4. Okay. 5. Okay, I agree. 6. The players should choose their top 3 players in a thread we create. Then the 6 players with more votes should be our roster for that all-star game. 1. Im not talking only about the possible difference in skills but about "national" vs "international" championships. I prefer the All-star game and there they can surprise me, I can say they have a chance in this and it could be intense match for me. 6. Thats bad idea, everyone will see the votes/choices in the thread above and it affect the next posts (like: "ok this player has many votes now, I can choose for my best 2nd, 3rd and 4th player" ... OR "ok, i would like to choose lorZ but nobody chose him above and he hasnt a chance now so I wont waste my 1 vote for him and I will vote for somebody else". - I think the players should vote in hidden mode. Via messages maybe? Messages can be posted to the new account named "SpaceSports" or "Admin" and we will check the number of votes in messages after deadline. And I think the number of votes by 1 player should be exactly the same as the number of players in the All-star team.
|
|
SanRoo
Free Agent
Posts: 307
Likes: 311
I am Offline
Last On: Dec 27, 2017 18:47:11 GMT 1
|
Post by SanRoo on Aug 18, 2014 14:06:27 GMT 1
1/3. What we doing now? Do we now the championship, the all-star game or both against the NSL? I think both options could be fun and interesting for everyone. So why not to try it? So lets see how this run and if the ppl. like it. If its not so good like both side wants, we can change and discuss it all the time. Maybe it won't work, but see it as a test.
2/5. I like this idea too, i would suggest that the community should choose the players for the our all-star game and we make a draw who will play in team A and who will play in team B to have fair teams. Because if we let the caps choose and it will be for example Insigne, he will choose Gotze and Tukk, and i bet he will only with with "his team" this game. So i'm against this captain idea, because we could make a fixed scheduled time for this game. I suggest that the teams should have a line-up from 5 players and the teams should choose his "cap" for themselves, so we don't need to vote a captain for this game.
6. I apreciate Vida's idea to vote in a hidden mode because no one will know who sombody voted for the All-Star Team and this wont have any impact on other votes too.
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Aug 18, 2014 14:21:21 GMT 1
1/3. What we doing now? Do we now the championship, the all-star game or both against the NSL? I think both options could be fun and interesting for everyone. So why not to try it? So lets see how this run and if the ppl. like it. If its not so good like both side wants, we can change and discuss it all the time. Maybe it won't work, but see it as a test. 2/5. I like this idea too, i would suggest that the community should choose the players for the our all-star game and we make a draw who will play in team A and who will play in team B to have fair teams. Because if we let the caps choose and it will be for example Insigne, he will choose Gotze and Tukk, and i bet he will only with with "his team" this game. So i'm against this captain idea, because we could make a fixed scheduled time for this game. I suggest that the teams should have a line-up from 5 players and the teams should choose his "cap" for themselves, so we don't need to vote a captain for this game. 6. I apreciate Vida's idea to vote in a hidden mode because no one will know who sombody voted for the All-Star Team and this wont have any impact on other votes too. 1/3 I preferred only All star game. We didnt decide yet that what we will play if only All-Star game or both Championships and AS-G. 2/5. Pls I told, that captains should choose the best captain due to the characteristics I said 4-5posts before. And all forum choose the best players, every player chooses and we count the votes in hidden mode. So in your example: Insigne cant choose his whole team but the forum can do it. But if insigne will be the captain (which I rly doubt) he can use his own rosters but also you can tell as admin to captain that it would be fine using all players.
|
|
lorZ
Administrator
Posts: 335
Likes: 340
I am Offline
Last On: Mar 19, 2017 0:01:37 GMT 1
|
Post by lorZ on Aug 18, 2014 18:35:55 GMT 1
SanRoo (I think), bonfire (I think) and I vote for playing All-Star game and the "Champions League".
Vida votes for only playing a All-Star game.
Please confirm your votes now, so we can start planning these events with the russians.
|
|
SanRoo
Free Agent
Posts: 307
Likes: 311
I am Offline
Last On: Dec 27, 2017 18:47:11 GMT 1
|
Post by SanRoo on Aug 18, 2014 19:04:51 GMT 1
I vote for playing the champions-cup and the all-star game.
|
|
Vida
Free Agent
Vesmirni Lide
Call me a spaceman!
Posts: 734
Likes: 679
I am Offline
Last On: Sept 12, 2020 0:34:11 GMT 1
|
Post by Vida on Aug 19, 2014 12:53:01 GMT 1
We play all, start planning!
|
|
bonfire
Free Agent
Motherfucker
Bon to the fire.
Posts: 292
Likes: 331
I am Offline
Last On: Nov 30, 2016 22:46:53 GMT 1
|
Post by bonfire on Aug 19, 2014 12:57:50 GMT 1
Yes, I am for both the All-star game and the Champions Cup/League
|
|